Scouting Scale

MLB Scouting Reports uses the 20-80 scale. All grades are for the players current value, and does not award higher grades for prospects or future potential. Here is a breakdown of each grade that you will see used on our site:

80 – Elite level pitcher/player, among the best of the best. Perennial Cy Young/MVP Candidate. Dominant and consistent impact. Future Hall of Famer.

75 – Elite level pitcher/player.  The best player on their team and a team leader. Perennial Cy Young/MVP Candidate.

70 – #1 starter, dominant closer or high end offensive performer. Frequent All-Star with the ability to challenge for Cy Young/MVP awards. One of the top players at their position.

65 – #2-3 starter, 2nd tier closer, premier setup man or strong offensive performer. Consistent All-Star contender, among the best players on their team.

60 – #3 starter, 3rd tier closer, premier reliever or above average offensive performer. Inconsistent All-Star contender, among the better players on their team. Able to maintain a starting role without question.

55 – #4 starter, bottom tier closer, strong reliever or slightly above average offensive performer. Virtually guaranteed a starting role but rarely if ever contends for All-Star appearances.

50 – #4-5 starter, 3rd-5th bullpen arm, average offensive performer. A big league average player who is guaranteed a roster spot but not a starting role. A role/platoon player.

45 – #5 starter, 5th-7th bullpen arm, a bench player. Players that struggle to keep a 25-Man roster spot for any considerable length of time. Strong minor league players.

40 – Emergency starter, swing man in the bullpen, part-time player. These players are starters in the minor leagues but rarely see much action in the big leagues.

35 – Non prospect player, who is a minor leaguer. May get a cup of coffee in the big leagues.

30 – Non prospect player, who is a career minor leaguer. Is only used to fill roster spots on minor league clubs, will not see any action in the big leagues.

25 – Non prospect player, who will not be drafted or will be released within the first years of their pro careers.

20 – Non prospect player who will not be drafted.

Advertisements

16 comments on “Scouting Scale

  1. Pingback: Derek Jeter’s Retirement | Taking Back Baseball

  2. Pingback: Qualifying Offer Claims Latest Victim, Cruz Signs 1yr/$8 million | Taking Back Baseball

  3. Pingback: Dan Shaughnessy: Rage Against the Dying of the Light | Taking Back Baseball

  4. Pingback: Defensive Analysis of Xander Bogaerts | Cat Vasgersian

  5. Pingback: The 30: Ten Toes In | Waves of Arms

  6. Pingback: A Trip Down Memory Lane with Thomas Boswell of the Washington Post (Part 1) | Taking Back Baseball

  7. Pingback: Boston Red Sox sign back Stephen Drew. WTF? | Taking Back Baseball

  8. Pingback: Baseball Reactions (6/30/2014) | Taking Back Baseball

  9. Pingback: My 2014 MLB All-Star Game Selections | Taking Back Baseball

  10. Pingback: Baseball Reactions (7-11-2014) | Taking Back Baseball

  11. Pingback: Welcome! « Baseball Breakdowns

  12. Pingback: The 2014 MLB Trade Deadline Spectacular Extravaganza! (Part 2) | Taking Back Baseball

  13. Pingback: Pleasant Surprises of the 2014 MLB Season (Part 1) | Taking Back Baseball

  14. Pingback: Pleasant Surprises of the 2014 MLB Season (Part 2) | Taking Back Baseball

  15. Pingback: Baseball Reactions (8-29-2014) | Taking Back Baseball

  16. Pingback: Baseball Reactions (9-5-2014) | Taking Back Baseball

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s